Labour formally drops £28bn green pledge and blames Tories for ‘crashing the economy’ – UK politics live | Politics
Labour says it won’t be able to spent £28bn per year on green investment because Tories crashed the economy
Labour has confirmed that it has formally dropped the its target of spending £28bn a year on green investment. It made the announcement in a briefing to journalists giving new details of its green prosperity plan.
The party said:
Labour has today announced plans to invest in Britain’s future, with Keir Starmer setting out further details of Labour’s mission to kick start growth and deliver clean power by 2030.
As part of the party’s finalisation of policies for a general election campaign, Labour has reconfirmed its commitment to the policies announced through the Green Prosperity Plan, to create jobs, cut bills and unlock investment.
The Green Prosperity Plan will be funded by a windfall tax on the oil and gas giants, and borrowing to invest within Labour’s fiscal rules.
The party also confirmed that, due to the Conservatives’ crashing the economy and Jeremy Hunt’s plans to ‘max out’ the country’s credit card, it would not be possible to reach the previous commitment of £28bn a year.
The centrepiece of the package is Great British Energy, a publicly owned energy company to take back control of the energy system on behalf of the British people.
Key events
-
Labour has ‘world-leading agenda on climate and energy’, says Ed Miliband, after £28bn target dropped
-
Labour says it won’t be able to spent £28bn per year on green investment because Tories crashed the economy
-
Gordon Brown defends dropping £28bn green investment target, saying Labour has to show ‘fiscal discipline’
-
Gordon Brown says he apologised as PM when he made mistakes, and Sunak should too
-
Scottish government to consider levy on shops to claw back profits from minimum unit price for alcohol as it rises by 30%
-
119 schools in England affected by Raac will have buildings replaced, DfE says
-
No-fault evictions up 49% in England year-on-year as campaigners complain renters reform bill being stalled
-
DfE says its Raac survey now complete and 234 schools in England found to have problem concrete
-
Penny Mordaunt implicitly criticises Sunak’s anti-trans jibe at PMQs, saying he should ‘reflect’ on his comments
-
Green industralist Dale Vince backs Labour’s move on £28bn, saying it’s ‘arbitrary figure’ and economic responsibility matters
-
Starmer to scale back home insulation scheme as part of green policy U-turn
-
Streeting says latest NHS figures show people ‘waiting longer for NHS treatment than ever before’
-
NHS figures show big increase in January in long waits in A&E in English hospitals
-
Michael Matheson resigns as Scotland’s health secretary over iPad roaming charges controversy
-
Sunak claims Labour’s U-turn show he’s right to say Starmer ‘doesn’t have a plan’
-
Sunak refuses to apologise for anti-trans jibe, saying linking what he said to Brianna Ghey tragedy was ‘worst of politics’
-
Tories claim that, despite Labour’s ‘attempted U-turn’, Starmer still committed to £28bn green investment plan
-
Minister defends Sunak’s transgender jibe amid calls for apology
-
Hospital waiting list for England fell slightly in December, for third month in row, figures show
-
Britain needs ‘more not less investment’, says Unite, as it urges Labour to resist Tories’ ‘false accusations’
-
Labour’s U-turn ‘will destroy Scottish jobs’, says SNP
-
Labour’s U-turn on £28bn green investment pledge ‘a massive backward step’, says Green party
-
‘Economically illiterate, strategically incompetent’ – Labour’s left criticises Starmer’s £28bn green investment U-turn
Labour has ‘world-leading agenda on climate and energy’, says Ed Miliband, after £28bn target dropped
Labour’s news release confirming the abandonment of the £28bn annual green investment target contains these quotes from Labour figures.
From Keir Starmer
I have changed the Labour party to put it back in the service of working people. Our Green Prosperity Plan is about turning a corner on fourteen years of Conservative decline and investing in Britain’s future. It is a plan for more jobs, more investment and cheaper bills. It’s a plan to get our country’s future back.
From Rachel Reeves, the shadow chancellor
Rachel Reeves, Shadow Chancellor, said:
Labour is ambitious for Britain’s future. There is a global race taking place in the jobs and industries of the future, and we are determined to lead it. All the Conservatives are offering the country is five more years of economic failure that will working people choice. Labour has a plan to invest and to get Britain’s future back.
And from Ed Miliband, the shadow energy secretary, said:
Labour will be fighting the election with a world-leading agenda on climate and energy with every single individual policy already announced now confirmed for the manifesto: Great British Energy, a National Wealth Fund, a Warm Homes Plan, a British Jobs Bonus, a Local Power Plan and no new oil and gas licences as well as our 2030 clean power mission.
It is thought that, of these three, Miliband will have been the one most reluctant to see the £28bn target go, because of his particuarly strong personal commitment to the net zero agenda. He has not been doing interviews recently, and the Conservative have been running a social media campaign suggesting he’s in hiding.
Labour says it won’t be able to spent £28bn per year on green investment because Tories crashed the economy
Labour has confirmed that it has formally dropped the its target of spending £28bn a year on green investment. It made the announcement in a briefing to journalists giving new details of its green prosperity plan.
The party said:
Labour has today announced plans to invest in Britain’s future, with Keir Starmer setting out further details of Labour’s mission to kick start growth and deliver clean power by 2030.
As part of the party’s finalisation of policies for a general election campaign, Labour has reconfirmed its commitment to the policies announced through the Green Prosperity Plan, to create jobs, cut bills and unlock investment.
The Green Prosperity Plan will be funded by a windfall tax on the oil and gas giants, and borrowing to invest within Labour’s fiscal rules.
The party also confirmed that, due to the Conservatives’ crashing the economy and Jeremy Hunt’s plans to ‘max out’ the country’s credit card, it would not be possible to reach the previous commitment of £28bn a year.
The centrepiece of the package is Great British Energy, a publicly owned energy company to take back control of the energy system on behalf of the British people.
Gordon Brown defends dropping £28bn green investment target, saying Labour has to show ‘fiscal discipline’
Gordon Brown has also defended Labour’s decision to drop £28bn as the annual target for spending on green investment. Asked about the move being confirmed today, Brown told LBC’s Tonight with Andrew Marr:
I haven’t seen any official announcement actually. But if that’s what he’s decided, it is because (Keir Starmer) and (Rachel Reeves, the shadow chancellor) have decided that they’ve got to abide by some fiscal discipline, given the state of the public finances.
You have got to remember when we left power in 2010, debt was below 40% of national income. It’s now 100% of our national income, I got criticised for allowing it to rise to 40%. Now it’s 100% and the Conservatives have got to take some responsibility for leaving a mess for the incoming government, whoever it is.
Aletha Adu
Rishi Sunak deliberately visited a dental practice that’s not accepting new adult NHS patients, Downing Street have said. (See 3.21pm and 3.26pm.)
The prime minister went to Gentle Dental in Newquay to promote his plans to offer cash incentives to dentists to accept more patients as more than 12 million were unable to get an appointment last year.
Sunak insisted the announcements this week will make a significant difference, and quickly”.
When asked if Sunak couldn’t find a practice accepting new patients, the prime minister’s deputy spokesperson said:
The prime minister wants to hear about the challenges surgeries are facing, and the challenges we’re trying to address through our dental plan … It’s right for the prime minister to hear from people on the frontline.
The Labour announcement about the future of the commitment to spend £28bn a year on green investment is coming at 5pm.
Rishi Sunak was in Cornwall today where he visited an dental surgery that does not accept adult NHS dental patients. (See 3.26pm.) He also visited Nancledra preschool where one of the people on the advisory board is Hannah Ray, a former colleague at the Guardian. I know that readers often wonder what the point of these visits is. Hannah was there, and she has been wondering about it too. She sent me this.
Rishi Sunak visited our preschool today, and completely missed the point. He did a puzzle with one of the children, looked at the guinea pigs, looked at the garden, and then took questions from the local press.
But while the press asked about second homes, his response to Brianna Ghey comments made at PMQs, and local council funding, no one – including the PM – seemed at all interested that the very preschool he was sitting in is under constant threat of closure due to lack of government funding into early years provision and lack of investment in early years staff training and incentives.
Government funding is now available for nearly all two-year-olds. However, the living wage has gone up by 9.8%. Staff are barely paid above the minimum wage yet have the biggest responsibility, working long hard hours to care for the most vulnerable people in society. The preschool is bursting at the seams with working parents wanting to get the childcare they need, but there aren’t the spaces.
Why did Rishi visit our preschool, in one of the most under-funded areas of the country, and one of the most deprived, if he didn’t really care about how it was doing?
Gordon Brown says he apologised as PM when he made mistakes, and Sunak should too
The former prime minister Gordon Brown has added his voice to those saying Rishi Sunak should apologise for his anti-trans jibe at PMQs yesterday. Asked about it in an interview for Sky’s Politics Hub with Sophy Ridge, Brown said:
Well, when I made mistakes, I did apologise. And look, every prime minister makes mistakes. I don’t think you can say that every prime minister will fail to make some mistakes, but I think you should apologise if you get things wrong and I mean it is a very sad and really tragic, tragic case of a family in grief.
I know he’s said he’s compassionate about the family, but perhaps he should do what I had to do on one or two occasions and apologise. And I do accept that if you make mistakes, you’ve got to correct them quickly.
Brown was giving an interview to highlight his concern about rising levels of extreme poverty in Britain, and his proposals for what should be done to address this. He has written about this in an article for the Guardian.
John Crace’s sketch is up, and it’s about Chris Philp’s media round this morning. You can read it here.
Nick Candy, a major Tory donor, thinks it is time for a Labour government, Alex Wickham from Bloomberg reports. He has posted about this on X.
Exclusive
— Property tycoon Tory donor Nick Candy says it’s “time for a change” of government to Labour
— praises Keir Starmer’s engagement with business
— blasts years of Tory infighting
— Nick Candy attended the PopCon launch two days ago with his wife Holly Valance
— he gave the Tories £100,000 in 2020 and backed Shaun Bailey for London mayor
— today he says it’s “probably time for a change” of government to Labour
— Candy criticises Labour’s private schools tax policy but praises Starmer
— he says: “we still don’t know the Labour policies, but do I think Keir Starmer is a decent man with good values and good morals? 100 percent”
Last week Helena Horton revealed that water company bosses and the chairs of the regulator Ofwat and the Environment Agency had a dinner together at an exclusive private members’ club to discuss issues like rising bills and sewage spills. Helena found out about this using a freedom of information request.
But this came as a surprise to the Liberal Democrats, because the party had also submitted FoI requests to try to find out what hospitality the Environment Agency boss has been receiving and this dinner was not disclosed. The Lib Dem MP Tim Farron suspects some sort of cover up, and he has written to Sir Laurie Magnus, the PM’s ethics adviser, to ask if the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, which is responsible for the Environment Agency, is in breach of the ministerial code. He has posted the letter on X.
Enough is enough. This is starting to stink of a cover up. I’ve called for an investigation into a possible breach of Ministerial code. DEFRA & EA are refusing to comply with requests for information. Maybe this cosy club between water firms & officials is worse than we feared
went for dinner at an exclusive private members’ club to discuss how to quell public anger over bill rises and sewage spills, the Guardian can reveal.
Scottish government to consider levy on shops to claw back profits from minimum unit price for alcohol as it rises by 30%
Severin Carrell
Scottish ministers are considering a new public health tax on shops after increasing the minimum price for alcohol by 30% in an effort to combat Scotland’s rising alcohol-related deaths and hospitalisations.
Shona Robison, the deputy first minister, confirmed a Guardian story earlier this week that the minimum unit price (MUP) will increase from 50p a unit to 65p, to keep pace with inflation and maintain fiscal pressures on alcohol abuse.
The new price will come into force on 30 September; it means a basic bottle of whisky will now cost £18.20, up from £14. “Alcohol harm remains a significant issue in Scotland,” she said. “It continues to contribute to worsening health outcomes,” particularly for men in deprived areas.
Scotland’s finance secretary, Robison also confirmed that ministers are considering demands for a new public health levy to claw-back the excess profits that shops earn from MUP, although she said the government already spends £112m a year on alcohol and drug treatment units.
The Fraser of Allander Institute at Strathclyde university estimates retailers have earned around £30m a year in unearned profits from MUP because they keep the difference between the higher price paid for drinks and the wholesale price of the product.
Scottish Labour and public health charities argue the case for a claw-back is now even greater; a higher 65p minimum price means higher unearned profits. Labour said the levy’s on proceeds should be spent on alcohol treatment and recovery projects.
Robison said they were consulting businesses and health experts on doing so, with a decision due before the next Scottish budget later this year. Scotland had a public health levy on large retailers between 2012 and 2015, which raised £95m.
The Scottish Retail Consortium said it welcomed the increased unit price but was furious at the prospect of an “unevidenced and unreasonable” new levy. “Any mooted tax rises are nothing more than a thinly veiled cash grab at the expense of an industry already under immense pressure,” it said.
Liz Truss is going to publish her book, Ten Years to Save the West – Lessons from the only conservative in the room, on 16 April, the publishers, Biteback, have announced.
In a news release about it, they say:
In Ten Years to Save the West, former prime minister Liz Truss reflects on the battles she fought – and too often lost – against the establishment during her ten years in government and sets out what conservatives and their allies across the western world must do in the years ahead if hostile regimes and increasingly extreme left-wing ideologies are to be defeated …
Ten Years to Save the West offers a timely warning about the perils facing conservatism in the years ahead if the agenda continues to be set in so many institutions – from the media to academia and the corporate world – by those espousing extreme ideologies, from the net zero zealots to the radical trans activists questioning basic scientific facts. If the west is to preserve the economic and cultural freedom and institutions that it holds so dear, Truss’s warnings need to be heeded.
Truss has secured a plug for her book from Boris Johnson, her predecessor, who says:
Liz Truss is right about one big thing – the old establishment economic models are failing. That’s bad news for the entire western world. And she is right that the last thing any of us now needs is more socialism, more taxes and more regulation. We need to reject that tiresome refrain of the global left and instead pursue an agenda that unleashes enterprise and boosts economic growth. I commend this invigorating tract!
The British Dental Association says that, in visiting a dental practice that is not taking new adult NHS patients (see 3.21pm), Rishi Sunak was seeing what the reality is for millions of people. The BDA’s chair Eddie Crouch said:
Rishi Sunak is seeing what life is like for millions across this country. The difference is he has options
The PM won’t have to queue around the block to get an appointment. He won’t face travelling hundreds of miles for care. He’ll never find himself reaching for a set of pliers.
The paucity of the government’s plan means many patients will keep facing these horrific choices.
The BDA has been fiercely critical of the government’s dental recovery plan published yesterday, saying it is “incapable of even beginning to honour Sunak’s promise to ‘restore’ NHS dentistry, or in any way meet the government’s stated ambition to provide access to NHS dentistry for ‘all who need it’”.
The dental practice Rishi Sunak visited in Cornwall today to promote his government’s dentistry plan is not accepting new adult NHS patients, PA Media reports. PA says:
The prime minister met staff and patients at Gentle Dental in Newquay on Thursday.
He told broadcasters that “it hasn’t been easy enough for people to access NHS dentistry over the past couple of years” but claimed “the announcements this week will make a significant difference, and quickly”.
“It’s a very significant new investment in dentistry so that everyone can get the access that they need,” Sunak said.
But the practice’s website states that it is not taking on new adult NHS patients or those entitled to free dental care.
Esther Ghey, whose daughter Brianna was murdered and who was in parliament yesterday when Rishi Sunak made an anti-trans jibe at PMQs, has said she does not want to comment on the row.
In a post on Facebook page of the Peace & Mind UK campaign she set up in her daughter’s memory, she wrote:
I don’t wish to comment on reports of wording or comments recently made. My focus is on creating a positive change and a lasting legacy for Brianna.
Through Peace & Mind, we want to improve lives by empowering people, giving them the tools they need to build mental resilience, empathy and self-compassion through mindfulness. In developing these skills, I hope that we can create a more understanding, peaceful and stronger society for everyone.
119 schools in England affected by Raac will have buildings replaced, DfE says
Richard Adams
The government has announced that 119 schools and colleges in England affected by reinforced autoclaved aerated concrete (Raac) will have buildings replaced as part of its long-term school rebuilding programme.
In a written statement, Gillian Keegan, the education secretary, said:
Our priority will always be to ensure the safety of pupils and staff, which is why we took a cautious approach for schools and colleges. Although the technical advice does not recommend removal in all cases where it is present, we have taken a precautionary approach for the education estate in England to remove Raac.
The Department for Education said its national survey of schools and colleges, with buildings dating from when Raac was widely used in construction, was now complete. Its final update added three more, including Barking and Dagenham College, a further education college in east London, and Thornleigh Salesian College, a secondary school in greater Manchester.
The DfE said that of the 234 found to have Raac-infested buildings, 119 are to get new buildings through its rebuilding programme, while 110 will receive grants to renovate or remove the affected parts. It said that “a small number” are still carrying out additional checks.
There are roughly 500 schools in England awaiting rebuilds, with about 50 completed every year, meaning that some schools could be waiting for several years before the work is completed.
Geoff Barton, general secretary of the Association of School and College Leaders, said the rebuilding effort was welcome but raised further questions over funding. He said:
Given the severe pressures on the school estate as a whole, we need assurances that this work will be funded wholly through additional capital expenditure and money will not be diverted from other sources. There must also be clear timelines set out for when this work is going to be completed.
The Raac crisis was exposed at the end of last summer, after the government received further evidence that buildings including Raac were in danger of decay and collapse. By the end of August, days before the start of the new school year, the Guardian revealed that the DfE was telling schools to make contingency plans against the risk of collapse. It then abruptly ordered more than 100 schools to close.
Paul Whiteman, general secretary of the National Association of Head Teachers, said:
While dealing with Raac is crucial, we really need to see more ambitious investment from the government to bring the schools estate up to scratch overall – from Raac, to asbestos, to general disrepair – it needs a plan to tackle all school building issues before they become the next big crisis. That can’t happen without more money from the Treasury.
No-fault evictions up 49% in England year-on-year as campaigners complain renters reform bill being stalled
Campaigners have criticised the government for delaying plans to ban no-fault evictions as new figures show a steep rise in repossessions in England, PA Media reports.
The latest statistics published by the Ministry of Justice show that some 26,311 accelerated possessions have been made from the second quarter of 2019 until the end of 2023.
Landlords can apply for an accelerated possession order if their tenants have not left by the date specified in a section 21 notice. Section 21 of the Housing Act allows no-fault evictions.
There were 9,457 such repossessions last year, up from 6,339 in 2022 – a 49% rise.
As the figures were released, Commons leader Penny Mordaunt outlined upcoming business in parliament but made no mention of the renters (reform) bill.
Labour’s Lucy Powell, responding in the Commons, complained that the report stage of the bill “was promised by early February, but it’s nowhere to be seen”.
In a statement, the party’s shadow minister for housing and planning, Matthew Pennycook, said: “The stark rise in section 21 notices served last year lays bare the devastating impact that the Tories’ failure to abolish them is having on hard-pressed renters.”
He vowed that if the government does not “get on and quickly pass the Bill abolishing section 21 evictions, that the next Labour government “will get the job done”.
Tom Darling, campaign manager of the Renters’ Reform Coalition, described the bill as “on life-support after being deprioritised by the government”.
Polly Neate, chief executive of Shelter, said: “It’s utterly shameful that the government is bowing to vested interests while renters are marched out of their homes in their thousands.”
And Ben Twomey, chief executive of Generation Rent, said: “Today sees the continuation of an awful trend that has been blighting the lives of renters across our country. As long as landlords can evict tenants through no fault of their own with just two months’ notice, homelessness in England will continue to soar.
“Renters have been waiting five years since the government promised to end these evictions, and yet today we find out the government is delaying their plans again. Since that promise, almost 90,000 households have been forced out because of no-fault evictions – and this number is rising every day.”