Byelections live: voting under way to replace Nadine Dorries and Chris Pincher | Byelections
My colleague Peter Walker has this report on the byelections today. The Conservatives are defending large majorities but given Rishi Sunak’s dismal poll ratings, the other parties have a chance to take the seats.
Voting has opened in Mid Bedfordshire and Tamworth in byelections seen as crucial in gauging the electoral fate of Rishi Sunak, but difficult to predict.
The Conservatives are defending majorities of nearly 25,000 in Mid Bedfordshire and close to 20,000 in Tamworth, which would normally point to an easy hold. However, their chances will be hampered by the party’s dismal poll ratings and the records of departing MPs.
The Mid Bedfordshire vote was triggered by the resignation of the former culture secretary Nadine Dorries in protest at her lack of a peerage from Boris Johnson’s resignation honours. Her protracted departure drew attention to her seemingly limited involvement in local affairs.
In Tamworth, Chris Pincher, the former deputy chief whip, stepped down from his seat after losing an appeal against an eight-week suspension from parliament for groping two men at a private members’ club in the summer of 2022.
Tamworth is a straight fight between the Conservatives and Labour. The latter held the Staffordshire seat between 1997 and 2010, when Pincher was first elected.
Sarah Edwards, the Labour candidate in Tamworth, is the bookmakers’ favourite to defeat the Conservatives’ Andrew Cooper, but this would need a swing of more than 21 percentage points.
Cooper has not helped his case after it emerged that in 2020 he shared a Facebook photo of a flowchart which said parents should only seek help with their finances if they were employed and gave up their TV and mobile phone contracts.
A Labour win would not be without precedent: a byelection in 1996 in South East Staffordshire, the previous seat in the area, saw Labour defeat the Conservatives with a swing of nearly 22 percentage points.
Mid Bedfordshire is even harder to call, given that both the Liberal Democrats and Labour have flung huge resources at the byelection.
Labour came a fairly distant second to Dorries in the 2019 general election, and argue this makes them the obvious challengers. The Lib Dems in turn say the seat’s largely rural demographics and the need to tempt wavering Tory voters to change sides mean they are better placed.
Read the full story here:
Welcome to today’s liveblog. I’m Nicola Slawson and I’m covering for Andrew Sparrow today. Do drop me a line if you have any questions or comments. I’m on [email protected] or @Nicola_Slawson on the site formerly known as Twitter.
Reminder: Please don’t tell us how you voted in the comments section – Election law (specifically section 66A of the Representation of the People Act 1983) makes it an offence to publish before the polls close at 10pm. Many thanks.
Key events
My colleagues Steven Morris and Diane Taylor have this on the return of asylum seekers to the Bibby Stockholm barge today:
Some of the men who have returned said they were frightened at the prospect of being made to live on the barge but were concerned that their asylum claims may be rejected if they resisted.
One told the Guardian: “I am worried and afraid. I do not want to go to the barge, but I don’t have the courage to disobey. I am literally helpless.
“I don’t know what is waiting for me. What will the government’s next pilot plans be for the men they are putting on the barge? We feel like pawns in their game, guinea pigs in their experiments. What experiment will they enact on us next? What is at the end of this devastating and crazy wait? Will I be able to save my life and my family?”
It is thought that about 30 men were on a bus that arrived at the port on Thursday lunchtime. Another 45 are believed to be arriving on Friday and Monday.
Dr Lisa Cameron, who quit the SNP for the Tories, has said she and Scotland are “exhausted by nationalism”.
Cameron caused a stir when she defected last week, after claiming she had been ostracised by SNP colleagues after supporting the young staffer who was sexually harassed by MP Patrick Grady, calling the party’s culture at Westminster “toxic”.
The defection sparked a war of words between Cameron and party members, with the SNP president, Mike Russell, describing her decision as a “tantrum” and first minister, Humza Yousaf, saying she must never have believed in an independent Scotland.
Speaking on BBC Radio 4’s Woman’s Hour on Thursday, Cameron was asked if she still believed in separation from the UK.
No I don’t. To be honest with you, I feel absolutely exhausted by nationalism.
I feel like Scotland’s exhausted by nationalism and all of our services are exhausted now. It’s become very divisive.
(The SNP) was badged to me in 2014 as a big, broad tent – it’s become narrower and narrower and narrower towards nationalism that I don’t even recognise the party I joined from 2014.
Cameron made her first appearance in the Commons as she crossed the floor before prime minister’s questions on Wednesday, flanked by the former prime minister Theresa May and the Scottish Tory leader, Douglas Ross.
The East Kilbride, Strathaven and Lesmahagow MP went on to say that her religion – she is a member of the Free Church of Scotland – had been “frowned upon” by some in the SNP.
She said:
I didn’t feel particularly wanted as a Christian in the SNP.
You were made to feel like you’re a Christian but just don’t raise it very much, certainly don’t vote in line with your beliefs.
I had voted against abortion regulation previously in the parliament and that had been another issue with the SNP.
Some people within the SNP had said at the time that I shouldn’t be able to be selected because of those issues as an MP last time.
There have been ongoing issues about not being able to be who I am, not being a big, broad tent of all different people from different political backgrounds.
People have gathered near the gates of Portland port to protest against the use of the Bibby Stockholm accommodation barge as asylum seekers were brought back onboard.
Candy Udwin, of Stand Up to Racism Dorset, said she had been in contact with some of those who had been staying on the Bibby Stockholm.
She said:
They hate it, they say it feels like a prison, some hate being on the sea, they find it very difficult to leave and they are completely separated from the community.
Annika, of Portland Global Friendship Group, had helped produce “welcome bags” for the arrivals, which included shampoo, toothpaste, notebooks and a map of the local area.
She said:
We just want to welcome the refugees and make a gesture to show there are people here who care.
I think the barge is a horrible idea, it feels very oppressive, it feels like a prison here with the amount of security that they have to go through.
A coach carrying asylum seekers to be accommodated on the Bibby Stockholm has arrived at Portland Port.
People protesting against the use of the barge also gathered at the gates of Portland Port on Thursday as the asylum seekers were brought back on board, PA News reports.
A number of people were being taken on board the vessel at the Dorset port more than two months after it was evacuated following the discovery of Legionella bacteria in the water supply.
A Home Office spokesperson said that tests for the bacteria, as well as improved fire safety protocols, had been completed before the return of the occupants to the barge.
The Daily Telegraph has reported that of the 39 people removed from the vessel in August, 29 would be returning.
Others had found accommodation with relatives, one had returned to their home country and others had mental health problems exempting them from staying on the barge.
Carralyn Parkes, mayor of Portland, who recently lost a high court fight against the home secretary, Suella Braverman, over the lawfulness of housing asylum seekers on the barge, attended the protest.
She said that she was continuing legal action against Dorset council as the planning authority responsible for the port.
She said:
The Bibby Stockholm is not the way humane society treats vulnerable human beings.
The Home Office said:
The government is committed to ending the use of expensive hotels for asylum seekers.
Moving asylum seekers into alternative accommodation sites, like the Bibby Stockholm, is more affordable for taxpayers and more manageable for communities, with on-site healthcare and catering facilities.
Steve Smith, chief executive of the refugee charity Care4Calais, said it was assisting asylum seekers with legal challenges against the accommodation.
He said:
That includes supporting the survivors of torture and modern slavery to legally challenge their accommodation on these sites, which is contrary to the government’s own suitability criteria.
Already, we are seeing some of these transfers being delayed or cancelled altogether because of these challenges.
Rishi Sunak will travel to Saudi Arabia after he has finished his visit with Benjamin Netanyahu in Israel, No 10 has announced.
The prime minister’s official spokesperson told reporters:
Later this afternoon, he is going to fly to Saudi Arabia to meet with Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman.
We will give further updates on his travel later on in the day.
Sunak is expected to return to the UK on Friday afternoon.
The principle of proportionality does not mean “an eye for an eye” as “that would be perverse”, the Commons leader has said.
Speaking during business questions in the Commons, Penny Mordaunt said:
There has been discussion over the last week of proportionality and the term collective punishment used on the floor of this house. I think it is incredibly important that we recognise that the International Committee of the Red Cross’s principle on proportionality is not meaning an eye for an eye as some have suggested.
That would be perverse. We are not suggesting via that very important principle that if the Israel Defence Forces (IDF) raided Gaza and beheaded a precise number of infants or burnt a precise number of families, or raped a precise number of women and girls, that that would be OK. Of course not. That’s not what proportionality means.
The principle of proportionality is seeking to limit damage caused by military operations. Requiring the effects of the means and methods of warfare must not be disproportionate to the military advantage sought. What Israel is trying to do is end Hamas, end a terror organisation which is a block to peace.
Mordaunt also noted the IDF are a “trained military force, who are subject to the rules of armed conflict and international law”, adding: “Their targeting doctrine and analysis of it is in the public domain and is subject to scrutiny. I don’t think that Hamas produce joint service publications, but if they did, it would say the opposite.”
Peter Walker
Next month’s state opening of parliament, one of the set-piece events in the UK political calendar, could face serious disruption after House of Commons security staff announced they would strike to coincide with it.
The Public and Commercial Services Union (PCS), which represents 250 parliamentary security staff who announced initial plans for a strike earlier this months, said any delays or queues on 7 November, when King Charles will deliver his first speech to parliament as monarch, would be the fault of management.
Parliamentary authorities plan to use extra police officers to cover the work of the security staff for the state opening, when large contingents of MPs, peers and other dignitaries descend on Westminster.
However, a PCS source said it remained possible there could be “serious delays” in people getting into the parliamentary estate, pointing to a strike by PCS security staff at courts last month, when about 30 closed despite efforts to mitigate the impact.
Unless there is a resolution, security staff will stop work from 7pm on 6 November until 7pm on 7 November, as well as for 24 hours from the evening of 31 October.
Any significant queues or delays to the state opening would be embarrassing for parliamentary staff. At the event, which starts a new session of parliament, the monarch delivers a speech in the House of Lords setting out the government’s legislative programme.
Read more here:
Penny Mordaunt has suggested the BBC needs to “kick the tyres” to ensure it meets the required broadcasting standards when reporting on the Israel-Hamas conflict.
The Conservative former minister Theresa Villiers told the Commons:
Could we have a debate on the reporting of the conflicts in the media between Israel and Hamas so that we can hold to account those media outlets that chose to rush to blame Israel for the hospital tragedy without having a sound evidential basis.
Accurate reporting is crucial, failing to deliver that makes the situation worse, could cost lives and fuel hatred and antisemitism back here in the UK.
The Commons leader, Mordaunt, replied:
There are two issues here. One is the Ofcom code and certain broadcasters’ adherence to it. In the guidance for that code it says ‘broadcasters should have regard to the list of proscribed terror groups or organisations in the UK’, and that is incredibly important.
But I also think it is critical that reporters – sometimes stationed in very stressful environments – need to be reporting facts as facts and those things that are not facts, that have not been verified or are lines to take from terrorist organisations should not be treated as facts. I think that’s very important.
I think the BBC does focus on these things to a very large degree but we know that sometimes it doesn’t get things right – as we saw recently with their code of conduct surrounding the Gary Lineker situation – so I’m sure they would want to kick the tyres and ensure that anyone listening to a BBC outlet is being given the best possible information.
The government’s new law aimed at giving more support to renters, including banning no-fault evictions, will make its first appearance in parliament on Monday, Penny Mordaunt has said.
The Commons leader said the renters reform bill would have its second reading in the Commons on Monday 23 October, PA reports.
The bill will make its first appearance in the Commons in the week before parliament is likely to rise for the end of the legislative session, a period known as prorogation.
The prime minister will not accept hormone-injected beef in the UK as a result of trade deals with other nations, the Commons has heard.
The shadow environment minister Daniel Zeichner told MPs:
To maintain that healthy, sustainable food system farmers need a level playing field. So when the member for North East Somerset (Sir Jacob Rees-Mogg) made his recent comments about the benefits of importing hormone-injected beef it sent a shudder through the industry.
Mogg recently suggested he favoured the import of hormone-injected beef from Australia, drawing the ire of farmers in his constituency.
Zeichner added:
Because this time last year, he was at the very top of government alongside the secretary of state. So can the minister, from his long experience in government, tell us how many others at the top of his government harbour this private view?
The environment minister Mark Spencer replied:
What I can say to him is the gentleman at the top of government, the prime minister, has been absolutely clear on this. He was absolutely explicit that we will not accept hormone-produced beef at any point in the future, nor will we accept chlorinated chicken.
He has the back of British farmers and their support, and he will do everything he can to help and support them.
International charities urge Sunak to push for an urgent ceasefire during Israel visit
Sam Jones
More than 60 international charities – including Action Aid UK, Bond, Cafod, Christian Aid, Islamic Relief, Médecins Sans Frontières UK, Oxfam GB and Save the Children UK – have signed a statement calling on the UK government to step up its efforts to secure an urgent ceasefire in Israel and Gaza following the bombing of al-Ahli al-Arabi hospital in Gaza and the escalating instability and humanitarian crisis in the region:
The horrific blast at al-Ahli al-Arabi Hospital in Gaza must serve as a wake-up call to the international community. We urge global leaders to call for an immediate ceasefire.
Without this there can be no safe humanitarian access which would allow NGOs and humanitarian agencies to urgently get food, clean water, and medical supplies into Gaza. Civilians, particularly women, the young and old, and people with disabilities, are already bearing the brunt of this escalating and tragic crisis and must be allowed to move to safety and be protected wherever they are.
The UK prime minister should urgently help secure a ceasefire and uphold UK’s responsibilities to ensure international humanitarian law is adhered to, to prevent further escalation and more lives being lost. It must act now to avoid a wider regional conflict.
Finally, we call on international actors to find a long-term, sustainable, just and peaceful solution for all people across the region.
Follow our Israel-Hamas war liveblog here:
Security minister Tom Tugendhat said the terror threat level is kept “under constant review”.
Asked on ITV’s Good Morning Britain whether there might be plans to raise the alert, he said:
It’s not a plan, because we don’t plan for the alert to change. We change the alert according to information that we get.
And it’s not done by politicians, quite correctly, it’s done by experts, the Joint Terrorism Analysis Centre.
He added:
I’m not going to be able to tell you much more than that, other than that we keep it under constant review.
Tugendhat alluded to the King’s speech on Wednesday about the need for “mutual understanding”, saying the level of “division” in society plays a part in how safe the UK is.
He said:
We are safer when we stand together, when we are careful of our language and when we are measured in how we talk about really emotive subjects like the incidents in the Middle East in the last few days.
Security minister Tom Tugendhat rejected an argument made by the government’s independent adviser for on extremism that Britain has become a “permissive environment” for antisemitism.
Asked on Times Radio whether he agreed with the comments, he said:
No, I don’t agree with that. I think that the United Kingdom is a country and an environemnt in which we take all threats to any communities extremely seriously.
You just have to look at the response over the last 10 days – the way the prime minister, the home secretary and I and many others have been reaching out to the Jewish community, making sure policing is appropriate… to give reassurance.
The way in which we’ve been engaging as well with the Muslim community, some of whom are feeling also vulnerable at this time, feeling stigmatised.
Tugendhat said it was a “perfectly legitimate” to march in support of Palestine as some people are, but that others are “championing a death cult”.
Pippa Crerar
In the world of expectation management, a “leaked” memo can be a useful tool for a political party on the eve of a tricky byelection. So the publication of an internal report prepared for the Conservative party chair, Greg Hands, was initially met with some scepticism.
The document, based on telephone canvassing data from recent days, claimed the Tory vote in Thursday’s two byelections in Tamworth and Mid Bedfordshire could halve to about 30%, creating more problems for Rishi Sunak.
In Mid Bedfordshire, where Nadine Dorries hung on for months after saying she would quit, the internal polling, seen by Sky News, suggested the Tories would lose even though it said Labour was trailing behind in the rural seat on 22% and the Lib Dems on 12%.
The memo also indicates a loss in Tamworth, where Chris Pincher stood down after drunkenly groping two men, and where there is a straight fight between the Tories and Labour.
Despite the leak, both results look far from clear cut. The Tories hold a majority of almost 25,000 in Mid Bedfordshire and it is 94 years since a party other than the Conservatives won the seat. The three-way nature of the contest means it will be a scrappy fight to the end.
Read more here:
Rishi Sunak arrives in Tel Aviv and warns against escalation of the conflict
Sam Jones
Rishi Sunak has arrived in Tel Aviv. As mentioned earlier, the British prime minister is due to meet his Israeli counterpart, Benjamin Netanyahu, and the Israeli president. Sunak is also expected to ask for aid to be allowed into Gaza and for Britons stranded there to be allowed to leave the area.
Reuters has these early remarks from the British prime minister.
After landing in Tel Aviv, Sunak told reporters:
Above all, I’m here to express my solidarity with the Israeli people. You have suffered an unspeakable, horrific act of terrorism and I want you to know that the United Kingdom and I stand with you.
In an early statement, he said the Gaza hospital blast on Tuesday that caused mass Palestinian casualties should be “a watershed moment for leaders in the region and across the world to come together to avoid further dangerous escalation of conflict”, adding that Britain would be at “the forefront of this effort”.
Sunak will also urge the opening up of a route to allow humanitarian aid into Gaza from Egypt as soon as possible, and to enable British nationals trapped in Gaza to leave.
“Every civilian death is a tragedy. And too many lives have been lost following Hamas’s horrific act of terror,” Sunak said.
At least seven British nationals have been killed and at least nine are still missing since the attack on Israel, Sunak’s spokesperson said on Wednesday.
The British foreign secretary, James Cleverly – who visited Israel last week – will travel to Egypt, Turkey and Qatar over the next three days to discuss the conflict and to seek a peaceful resolution, his office said.
You can follow our dedicated Israel-Hamas war liveblog, where my colleague Sam Jones will be covering more from Sunak’s visit, here:
My colleague Peter Walker has this report on the byelections today. The Conservatives are defending large majorities but given Rishi Sunak’s dismal poll ratings, the other parties have a chance to take the seats.
Voting has opened in Mid Bedfordshire and Tamworth in byelections seen as crucial in gauging the electoral fate of Rishi Sunak, but difficult to predict.
The Conservatives are defending majorities of nearly 25,000 in Mid Bedfordshire and close to 20,000 in Tamworth, which would normally point to an easy hold. However, their chances will be hampered by the party’s dismal poll ratings and the records of departing MPs.
The Mid Bedfordshire vote was triggered by the resignation of the former culture secretary Nadine Dorries in protest at her lack of a peerage from Boris Johnson’s resignation honours. Her protracted departure drew attention to her seemingly limited involvement in local affairs.
In Tamworth, Chris Pincher, the former deputy chief whip, stepped down from his seat after losing an appeal against an eight-week suspension from parliament for groping two men at a private members’ club in the summer of 2022.
Tamworth is a straight fight between the Conservatives and Labour. The latter held the Staffordshire seat between 1997 and 2010, when Pincher was first elected.
Sarah Edwards, the Labour candidate in Tamworth, is the bookmakers’ favourite to defeat the Conservatives’ Andrew Cooper, but this would need a swing of more than 21 percentage points.
Cooper has not helped his case after it emerged that in 2020 he shared a Facebook photo of a flowchart which said parents should only seek help with their finances if they were employed and gave up their TV and mobile phone contracts.
A Labour win would not be without precedent: a byelection in 1996 in South East Staffordshire, the previous seat in the area, saw Labour defeat the Conservatives with a swing of nearly 22 percentage points.
Mid Bedfordshire is even harder to call, given that both the Liberal Democrats and Labour have flung huge resources at the byelection.
Labour came a fairly distant second to Dorries in the 2019 general election, and argue this makes them the obvious challengers. The Lib Dems in turn say the seat’s largely rural demographics and the need to tempt wavering Tory voters to change sides mean they are better placed.
Read the full story here:
Welcome to today’s liveblog. I’m Nicola Slawson and I’m covering for Andrew Sparrow today. Do drop me a line if you have any questions or comments. I’m on [email protected] or @Nicola_Slawson on the site formerly known as Twitter.
Reminder: Please don’t tell us how you voted in the comments section – Election law (specifically section 66A of the Representation of the People Act 1983) makes it an offence to publish before the polls close at 10pm. Many thanks.
